Alberta premier urges Biden to show Canada ‘respect’ on Keystone XL file

Alberta premier urges Biden to show Canada ‘respect’ on Keystone XL file

By

Kirby Bourne

630CHED

Posted January 18, 2021 1:14 pm

 
 

Updated January 18, 2021 3:35 pm

4:00
Alberta has strong legal argument if Keystone XL expansion is killed in U.S.: Jason Kenney

Premier Jason Kenney said Alberta has a strong legal basis for seeking damages if the Keystone XL pipeline expansion is killed – something Joe Biden reportedly plans to do on his first day as president. Tom Vernon and Mike Le Couteur have team coverage on the noon news.


  • comments

    Leave a comment


  • whatsapp

    Share this item via WhatsApp


  • more

    Share this item


  • more

    Share this item

Smaller font
Descrease article font size
-A

Larger font
Increase article font size
A+



  • Share this item via WhatsApp

    whatsapp



  • Share this item on Pinterest

    pinterest



  • Share this item on LinkedIn

    linkedin



  • Share this item on Reddit

    reddit



  • Copy article link

    Copy link

The premier of Alberta is condemning Joe Biden‘s plan to scrap the Keystone XL pipeline expansion on his first day as U.S. president.

Biden’s plan is outlined in transition documents seen by The Canadian Press.

The documents suggest that despite its best efforts, Canada has failed to convince the incoming administration of the virtues of importing fossil-fuel energy from a friendly ally and trading partner with similar climate change goals.

Jason Kenney says halting construction on the controversial project will be disastrous for both the Canadian and U.S. economies and their relationship.

“That would be, in our view, an economic and strategic error that would set back Canada-U.S. relations with the United States’ most important trading partner and strategic ally: Canada,” Kenney said on Monday morning.

Read more:
Biden plans to block Keystone XL pipeline with day 1 order, documents show

Story continues below advertisement

According to Kenney, Biden’s transition team is not communicating with foreign governments “given events over recent years.” But Alberta’s premier is urging the team to change that policy in this case because of the relationship between the two countries.

“All we ask at this point is that president-elect Biden show Canada respect to actually sit down and hear our case about how we can be partners in prosperity, partners in combating climate change, partners in energy security.”

Kenney says his government — which announced a $1.5-billion investment in the expansion last year — is prepared to “use all legal avenues available to protect its interest in the project.”

8:30
Kenney urges Biden to reconsider decision to block Keystone XL, says it will harm U.S. energy independence

Kenney urges Biden to reconsider decision to block Keystone XL, says it will harm U.S. energy independence

He said the province has hired lawyers in both Canada and the U.S. and believes they have a “very strong” case for any legal recourse.

Story continues below advertisement

“This is, I believe, without precedent for an American administration retroactively to seek to cancel a piece of infrastructure that already exists.

Tweet This

“Costs have been incurred and if the project is effectively killed by a presidential veto of this nature – a retroactive veto – we believe that under the Canada-United States-Mexico trade agreement and other international trade agreements that there would be a solid legal basis to, at the very least, seek damages.”

Read more:
Scott Moe ‘disappointed’ with Joe Biden’s plan to cancel Keystone XL pipeline

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has so far been silent on the issue, but his ambassador to the U.S., Kirsten Hillman, is defending the pipeline, saying it fits into Canada’s climate plan and promises good jobs.

In a statement to Global News, federal Minister of Natural Resources Seamus O’Regan said Canada is looking forward to working with the incoming U.S. administration, but said it will continue to make the case for Canadian oil.

“Canadian oil is produced under strong environmental and climate policy frameworks, and this project will not only strengthen the vital Canada-U.S. energy relationship, but create thousands of good jobs for workers on both sides of the border.

“Workers in Alberta and across Canada will always have our government’s support.”

Story continues below advertisement

1:28
Green party leader says Canada shouldn’t push Biden admin to reverse Keystone XL pipeline cancellation

Green party leader says Canada shouldn’t push Biden admin to reverse Keystone XL pipeline cancellation

In a statement, MP for Calgary Nose Hill Michelle Rempel Garner, said the cancelation of the project would have “significant” negative impacts for workers on both sides of the border.

Trending Stories

  • Canada OKs troubled Boeing 737 MAX 8 jets to resume service this week

  • Biden plans to block Keystone XL pipeline with day 1 order, documents show

“This project stands to create thousands of jobs and is a project of national significance,” she said.

Tweet This

“At a time when we should be strengthening the bilateral relationship between our countries, looking for ways to take energy off of rail cars and into safer transport methods and reducing our dependence on energy produced in countries with far less rigorous environmental standards then our own, the cancellation of this project should not happen.”

Read more:
Biden’s Keystone XL decision could be ‘tough’ moment for Canada, U.S. ties: senator

In a statement, the Canadian Association of Petroleum producers said it was “concerned” by the reports the pipeline will be cancelled.

Story continues below advertisement

“Cancelling Keystone XL would immediately kill thousands of U.S. and Canadian jobs, harm energy security and integration in North America, and have a negative effective on the economic recovery in both countries,” president and CEO Tim McMillan said.

“This pipeline would supply the U.S. market with sustainably produced, high-demand heavy oil. Without it, the U.S. will have to import more oil, from places such as Venezuela, who do not share their concern for the environment or climate change.”

According to McMillan, CAPP will work with all involved parties — including government, unions and Indigenous communities — to try and find a way to complete the pipeline.

If the permit is pulled, Kenney said he will sit down with TC Energy Corp. and the government of Canada to determine next steps.

Province has no legal recourse: expert

Despite Kenney’s claims, an associate professor at the University of Calgary’s Faculty of Law says the province has no viable path to legal action.

Kristen van de Biezenbos said TC Energy has a few options though. They could first refile a lawsuit they filed in 2015 in U.S. federal court claiming a president does not have the authority to permit or stop a pipeline border crossing. That lawsuit was removed when President Trump was elected because he promised to permit the crossing.

Story continues below advertisement

Second, the company could file an arbitration claim with the Canada-United States-Mexico agreement, or the new NAFTA. But van de Biezenbos said the U.S. has never lost an arbitration case within NAFTA.

4:00
Alberta has strong legal argument if Keystone XL expansion is killed in U.S.: Jason Kenney

Alberta has strong legal argument if Keystone XL expansion is killed in U.S.: Jason Kenney

Finally, TC Energy could file a takings claim in U.S. federal court to cover its losses.

The only option that could see the permit reinstated though is refiling the 2015 lawsuit.

“None of them are particularly good,” she said.

The only way she sees Alberta recouping the investment it made in the pipeline is if there was something in the loan guarantee that said TC Energy would have to compensate the province if it wasn’t able to complete the project.

“But if you’re talking about damages from the U.S. government, I don’t see how,” she said.

Story continues below advertisement

“It’s difficult to argue reasonable reliance when you know that the permit has been issued via presidential permit.”

Tweet This

The reason that argument is difficult is because a presidential permit is a “risky endeavor” she said. Whenever a president give a project the go ahead in that way, it can be revoked whenever a president feels like it.

“President Trump could have revoked Keystone XL’s permit if he just got upset with Prime Minister Trudeau, with Canada, he could have done it at any time. So similarly, once he becomes the president, Biden can also revoke it at any time.”

Read more:
Feds laying groundwork to ensure Biden hears Canada’s priorities, ambassador says

Van de Biezenbos added she can’t remember a time when the Alberta government lost this much money on a single investment.

“I also don’t know if the province has ever put its money on such a risky endeavor. It was so much money to put on a project that – it was entirely foreseeable that it would be cancelled. It’s one of the things Vice President Biden campaigned on.”

The immediate loss to taxpayers if the permit is cancelled is about $1 billion, Kenney said.

Follow @Kirby_Bourne

Story continues below advertisement

– With files from the Canadian Press

© 2021 Global News, a division of Corus Entertainment Inc.

Leave a comment

Comments

Jason KenneyJoe BidenPipelinesAlberta oilsandsKeystone XLKeystone XL pipelineAlberta pipelineTC Energy CorpKeystone XL Pipeline ExpansionJoe Biden Keystone XLJason Kenney Keystone XLJason Kenney Keystone XL cancelledJoe Biden Jason KenneyJoe Biden Keystone XL cancelled

Leave a comment

Comments

More from Global News

  • Calgary hosts ‘bubble’ camp for Canadian women’s hockey team

  • N.S. becomes 1st province to have ‘opt-out’ organ donation. Will the rest of Canada follow?

Advertisement

Tagged , , ,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *